Worry of the Week – 1 November 2015: Bangladesh

Dipon, Faisal Arefin

Faisal Arefin Dipon (Source: The Friendly Atheist)

For the fifth time this year, I’ve woken to news that another person associated with the tiny atheist community in Bangladesh has been brutally murdered via machete.

In February it was author and atheist blogger Dr Avijit Roy, who was murdered in the street in a machete attack. Then on 30 March atheist blogger Washiqur Rahman (27) was murdered in another machete attack in the street outside his home. Next, on 12 May, was Ananta Bijoy Das. Das contributed to an atheist blog originally set up by Dr Roy, and was also killed in a machete attack in the street. On 6 August, Niloy Chatterjee (40), an organizer of the Science and Rationalists’ Association of India, was found in his home with his hands and head cut off.

This time it’s a publisher of Dr Avijit Roy’s books, 43-year-old Faisal Arefin Dipon head of the Jagriti Prakashani publishing house. His body was found in the company offices by his father, the writer Abul Kashem Fazlul Haq. According to the AFP reports he said:

“I saw him lying upside down and in a massive pool of blood. They slaughtered his neck. He is dead.”

Dhaka ahmed-rashid-tutul-avijit-bonya

Ahmed Rashid Tutul (centre) at his publishing house book stall at the Dhaka International Book Fair, 26 February 2015. This is the night Avijit Roy (right) was murdered, and Roy’s wife Rafida Ahmed (left) was seriously injured. (Source: IHEU)

Earlier the same day three secular bloggers were injured in an attack. One of the men, Ranidipam Basu appears to have suffered only minor injuries. There is a picture of him in a BBC article lying on a stretcher with his eyes closed. However, the IHEU (International Humanist and Ethical Union) says he was personally confirming his survival on Facebook soon afterwards. The other two were Tareq Rahim, who was also a poet, and Ahmed Rashid Tutul, who was also a publisher and had published Dr Roy’s work in the past.  Rahim and Tutul are in hospital and, according to the IHEU, in a critical condition. The BBC reports that “at least one” is in a critical condition.

In what has become typical of attacks on atheists in Bangladesh, all four men were attacked using machetes.

Tutul’s publishing house is called Shuddho-Shor (শুদ্ধস্বর‌), which means “Pure Voice”. The IHEU says it, “… is popular among progressive, secular writers and readers, and has continued to publish despite receiving numerous direct threats against the lives of those working there.”

From the IHEU website:

We are Bangladesh HumanistsThe International Humanist and Ethical Union (IHEU) has repeatedly criticised police and officials’ handling of the string of attacks, and in August organised alongside a number of secular Bangladeshi writers and academics a mass joint letter of protest to the Bangladesh Government.

IHEU Director of Communications, Bob Churchill, comments: “We know what comes next because we’ve seen it before. In a few weeks or months, police and media will perform a merry dance, arresting and parading a few different groups or individuals detained in connection with the latest attack. They’ll parade someone for the cameras. Then there will be no trial, no true justice. And the same thing will happen again and again.

“How many more times must we see these bloody and callous acts of hatred before the authorities wake up to the true problem. Officials must stop threatening to arrest, and stop blaming atheists themselves for writing books and blogs. To victim-blame them will continue to empower the fundamentalist killers and undermine the very basis of secular democracy itself.

“Though there are many similarities with earlier outrages, today’s coordinated attacks may represent a significant emboldening and an up-step in the campaign to terrorize and silence the voices of humanists, atheists and secularists. The Bangaldeshi authorities must now accept that their failure to achieve justice and the appeasement of fundamentalist violence is not working, and is costing life after life.”


An anti-atheist rally in Dhaka, Bangladesh.

I can only agree. I’ve written before about the reactions of many in Bangladesh to the brutal murder of secularists in that country. Victim-blaming is the norm. Given that atheists are speaking out via blogs and books, which no-one is obliged to read, and they’re breaking no laws (Bangladesh is a secular democracy), I can’t for the life of me see that atheists are the ones at fault here.

The solution in their opinion is for atheists to not antagonize others. Twice before I’ve quoted the appalling words of Dr Rupak Bhattacharjee, and I’m going to repeat them again:

The young bloggers are also required to guard against recklessness and any radical interpretation of people’s faith in a traditional society like Bangladesh as that may only end up arousing raw emotion and disturbing social harmony.

Personally, I think the attitude of someone calling for the death sentence because of a person’s failure to believe in their god is far more egregious. The Islamist groups in Bangladesh publish the names and addresses of the people they think should be killed as enemies of Islam, and openly call for their murder. They genuinely believe they are doing what is right, to please their god. This is why secular society that promotes the values of freedom of speech and freedom of religion (or no religion) is so important. Those values are in the Bangladesh constitution, but the government all too often caves to Islamist extremists in order to retain political power. The complaints that the IHEU raises about the Bangladesh government are completely valid. The problem is, the situation is likely to be worse if the main opposition regains power, as they are less committed to secularism. In the past they allowed Islam to be named the national religion of the country, in opposition to the constitution.

7 Responses to “Worry of the Week – 1 November 2015: Bangladesh”

  1. Mark R. says:

    This brings perspective to my US political woes. No matter how bad it gets here with the Plutocracy rising, it is nothing in comparison to this Bangladesh horror. I could definitely be killed for my interpretation of reality if I were placed in an Islamic theocracy. Is it really 2015? It’s hard to wrap my mind around these religion-based atrocities. It’s as dumb as people who believe in a flat earth killing those who know the earth is round. I don’t care what others believe, but why kill (KILL!) someone who believes differently? So so so so dumb. Happy Halloween.

  2. paxton marshall says:

    This is a terrible thing, but in the US murders are a daily occurrence. Nine people were killed in a church in South Carolina because they were black. Others are killed because they are kids. Cops kill people on a regular basis. We send our kids off to be killed invading countries for the benefit of the plutocracy. Parents and other church members beat their kids to death if they question their religion. Martin Luther King was assassinated for working for racial justice. Catholic hospitals refuse abortions to save the mother’s life. We send non-violent drug offenders to prison to be raped and abused. I’m not saying we shouldn’t object to this string of murders, just replying to Mark’s comment that nothing happens here to compare with Bangladeshi horror.

    • Mark R. says:

      Yes, atrocities happen all over the world from religious tensions, racial tensions, political tensions, etc. Though it is a false equivalency to compare the Bangladeshi murder(s) (and other murders for apostates) with the US murders you cited. I was specifically ranting about being killed for what one believes in (or doesn’t believe in) metaphysically. Respectfully, your examples are outside that frame. I’m not saying that it could never happen here, but until I’m fearful of writing that I’m an atheist on a web site, I will stand by my original point that it’s a hell of a lot safer to live in the US as an atheist than most (all?) Islamic theocracies.

      • paxton marshall says:

        I agree that you’re not likely to be murdered in the US for being an atheist, but you’re not likely to be elected to office either, not even dogcatcher.

  3. nicky says:

    I have said it before, and will say it again. The problem is Islam itself. It appears notoriously nearly hermetically closed -never mind Mr Nawaz’s efforts- to any kind of doubt, criticism or enlightenment.
    I read (and was read) the Bible, and it was instrumental in me becoming an ateist. It is a totalitarian, evil compilation.
    The Islamic trilogy (Qur’an, Hadith and Syrah) is worse, almost incomparably worse. About everything you do not like in Christianity is squared in Islam.
    I have very little hope for Bangla Desh, (and for Europe, I fear it is a lost case too).
    It should not be a ‘worry of the week’, but a ‘worry of the century’, immo.

    • The problem of conservative Islam is fairly recent. Imo it can be blamed almost entirely on Saudi money. They got rich from oil and used it to spread Wahhabism. We’re suffering the fallout from this.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.